All opinions posted. None too pathetic or contrived. Everyone gets their say.

"...even the wicked get worse than they deserve." - Willa Cather, One of Ours

Friday, May 21, 2004

A call to conscience

Salon (Liberal)
The diplomat who quit over Nixon's invasion of Cambodia asks Americans on the front lines of foreign service to resign from the "worst regime by far in the history of the republic."
...The women and men of our diplomatic corps and intelligence community are genuine trustees. With intellect and sensibility, character and courage, you represent America to the world. Equally important, you show the world to America. You hold in trust our role and reputation among nations, and ultimately our fate. Yours is the gravest, noblest responsibility. Never has the conscience you personify been more important...

[...]

You know that showcase resignations at the top -- Defense Secretary Donald Rumsfeld or flag officers fingered for Abu Ghraib -- change nothing, are only part of the charade. It is the same with Secretary of State Colin Powell, who may have been your lone relative champion in this perverse company, but who remains the political general he always was, never honoring your loss by giving up his office when he might have stemmed the descent.

No, it is you whose voices are so important now. You alone stand above ambition and partisanship. This administration no longer deserves your allegiance or participation. America deserves the leadership and example, the decisive revelation, of your resignations.

Your resignations alone would speak to America the truth that beyond any politics, this Bush regime is intolerable -- and to an increasingly cynical world the truth that there are still Americans who uphold with their lives and honor the highest principles of our foreign policy.

[...]

As you consider your choice now, beware the old rationalizations for staying -- the arguments for preserving influence or that your resignation will not matter. Your effectiveness will be no more, your subservience no less, under the iron grip of the cabal, especially as the policy disaster and public siege mount. And your act now, no matter your ranks or numbers, will embolden others, hearten those who remain and proclaim your truths to the country and world.

[...]

...Three ranking Foreign Service officers -- Mary Wright, John Brady Kiesling and John Brown -- resigned in protest of the Iraq war last spring. Like them, you should join the great debate that America must now have.

Unless and until you do, however, please be under no illusion: Every cable you write to or from the field, every letter you compose for Congress or the public, every memo you draft or clear, every budget you number, every meeting you attend, every testimony you give extends your share of the common disaster.

The America that you sought to represent in choosing your career, the America that once led the community of nations not by brazen power but by the strength of its universal principles, has never needed you more. Those of us who know you best, who have shared your work and world, know you will not let us down...
A few days ago Ricks of the WaPo wrote a story filled with anonymous quotes from Pentagon officials and senior military officers proclaiming the war in Iraq lost, and that we should divide the country, appoint a friendly dictator, and get out now. They said that doing anything less ran the risk of destroying the US Army.

This is very strong stuff. But I immediately discounted it as self-congratulatory whining. Why? Because not one of these people have resigned or expressed an intention or willingness to resign.

If things are as bad as they say, then they have an explicit duty to this country to resign and denounce the Bush administration. The idea that they would continue to play along with this massive level of corruption and incompetence in unfathomable. The fact that they express these strong opinions and still don’t resign tells me that these anonymous voices are those of intellectual and moral cowards. Such people have no credibility.

The same is true, but to a lesser extent, of the war critics in the State Department. Several honorable senior members of the diplomatic service resigned in protest before the invasion. I admire that tremendously, and these people deserve the approbation of all the American public.

But these resignations failed to stop the war, and since then, no other senior State Department official has backed up his criticism of Bush policy by resigning. If Powell and associates truly believe what they are telling the media on background, then they have a duty to resign immediately. Since they have not done so, I treat these anonymous critics the same way I do those similar voices in the Department of Defense. Displaying moral cowardice in the face of a national crisis does not lead me to give them much credibility at all.

I will know when these critics of Bush policy are serious, and not just engaging in self-aggrandizing whining, when there are some highly vocal and significant resignations from their comfortable jobs. If they mean what they say then doing so is their duty to the Republic.

I am waiting…

Comments: Post a Comment

<< Home