More About Me...
Email Me
Current Endeavor:
Sandy Matheson for Congress
Friends & Family
Middle East
- Back to Iraq 3.0
- Baghdad Burning
- DEBKAfile
- Deeds
- Hammorabi
- Healing Iraq
- Iraq & Iraqis
- Iraq at a glance
- IRAQ THE MODEL
- Kevin Sites
- Kurdo's World
- SISTANI.ORG
- THE MESOPOTAMIAN
Military
- Blackfive
- Boots on the Ground
- Dagger JAG
- Doc in the Box
- Coalition Casualties
- IRAQ NOW
- Sgt Hook
- StrategyPage
Media/Tech
- Ars Technica
- Command Post - War News
- EURSOC
- Gawker
- Gizmodo
- Media Notes-Kurtz
- Poynter Online - Romenesko
- Slashdot
- Wonkette
Humor
Liberal
- Altercation
- Daily Howler
- Eschaton - Atrios
- Greg Easterbrook
- The New Republic
- Political Animal
- Talking Points Memo
by Joshua Micah Marshall - TAP
- Wampum
Conservative/Libertarian
- Andrew Sullivan.com
- A Small Victory
- Belmont Club
- Citizen Smash
- Daniel W. Drezner
- InstaPundit
- Little Green Footballs
- Outside the Beltway
- Tim Blair
- The Volokh Conspiracy
- Winds of Change
Reciprocal Links
Archives
- Sunday, March 21
- Monday, March 22
- Tuesday, March 23
- Wednesday, March 24
- Thursday, March 25
- Friday, March 26
- Saturday, March 27
- Sunday, March 28
- Monday, March 29
- Wednesday, March 31
- Friday, April 02
- Saturday, April 03
- Sunday, April 04
- Monday, April 05
- Tuesday, April 06
- Wednesday, April 07
- Thursday, April 08
- Friday, April 09
- Saturday, April 10
- Sunday, April 11
- Monday, April 12
- Wednesday, April 14
- Thursday, April 15
- Friday, April 16
- Saturday, April 17
- Sunday, April 18
- Monday, April 19
- Tuesday, April 20
- Wednesday, April 21
- Thursday, April 22
- Friday, April 23
- Saturday, April 24
- Sunday, April 25
- Monday, April 26
- Tuesday, April 27
- Wednesday, April 28
- Thursday, April 29
- Friday, April 30
- Saturday, May 01
- Sunday, May 02
- Monday, May 03
- Tuesday, May 04
- Wednesday, May 05
- Thursday, May 06
- Friday, May 07
- Saturday, May 08
- Sunday, May 09
- Monday, May 10
- Tuesday, May 11
- Wednesday, May 12
- Thursday, May 13
- Friday, May 14
- Saturday, May 15
- Sunday, May 16
- Monday, May 17
- Tuesday, May 18
- Wednesday, May 19
- Thursday, May 20
- Friday, May 21
- Saturday, May 22
- Sunday, May 23
- Monday, May 24
- Tuesday, May 25
- Wednesday, May 26
- Thursday, May 27
- Friday, May 28
- Saturday, May 29
- Sunday, May 30
- Monday, May 31
- Tuesday, June 01
- Wednesday, June 02
- Thursday, June 03
- Friday, June 04
- Saturday, June 05
- Monday, June 07
- Monday, June 14
- Tuesday, June 15
- Wednesday, June 16
- Thursday, June 17
- Friday, June 18
- Saturday, June 19
- Monday, June 21
- Tuesday, June 22
- Wednesday, June 23
- Thursday, June 24
- Friday, June 25
- Monday, June 28
- Tuesday, June 29
- Wednesday, June 30
- Thursday, July 01
- Friday, July 02
- Monday, July 05
- Tuesday, July 06
- Wednesday, July 07
- Thursday, July 08
- Friday, July 09
- Saturday, July 10
- Monday, July 12
- Tuesday, July 13
- Wednesday, July 14
- Thursday, July 15
- Friday, July 16
- Saturday, July 17
- Sunday, July 18
- Monday, July 19
- Friday, July 23
- Monday, July 26
- Tuesday, July 27
- Wednesday, July 28
- Thursday, July 29
- Friday, July 30
- Current Posts
All opinions posted. None too pathetic or contrived. Everyone gets their say.
"...even the wicked get worse than they deserve." - Willa Cather, One of Ours
Saturday, April 10, 2004
Weakness can kill
THE MESOPOTAMIAN
2004_04_01_messopotamian_archive.html#108162646725023460
...I don’t presume to be able to give a knowledgeable critique about U.S. and Allied strategy, like everybody seems to be fond of doing nowadays (and there doesn’t seem to be a shortage of Gurus of the subject). Firmness would have been much easier to apply at a much earlier stage. When I say “Firmness”, it must not be construed to mean brutality. Nevertheless, and undeniably, the use of force is part of the thing, but it must be precise, measured and proportionate. This, of course, is almost stating the obvious.http://messopotamian.blogspot.com/
One thing is fundamental though: Once you start exercising firmness it will be disastrous if you falter and show weakness again. Diplomacy and politics are essential of course, but the arguments of the strong are always much more convincing. In any case I ask all our friends not to be too emotional and weak stomached, and above all not to help the enemy in what he is desperate to achieve, i.e. defeatism and despair...
2004_04_01_messopotamian_archive.html#108162646725023460
Poisonous media supporting terrorist
Hammorabi (Iraqi Shia fm Baghdad)
Important Points!
2004_04_01_hammorabi_archive.html#108162951818939215
Important Points!
...Again the terrorist media Al Jazeera and Al Arabia TVs showed the two tapes for some thugs holding knifes and threatening to kill innocent Japanese in the name of Islam. Islam has nothing to do with the criminals who use its name for their own purposes. Islam means peace and the way these criminal terrorist use have nothing to do with it but with the devilish way of the Wahabist and other terrorists in the region and the world. Strict measure should apply on all non-respected terrorist supporter Arab media and the BBC Arabic service...http://hammorabi.blogspot.com/archives/
2004_04_01_hammorabi_archive.html#108162951818939215
Other Dangers in Iraq
Blackfive
http://www.blackfive.net/main/2004/04/camel_critters.html
...He was recently bitten by a camel spider which was hiding in his sleeping bag. I thought you'd like to see what a camel spider looks like. It'll give you a better idea of what our troops are dealing with. Enclosed is a picture of his friend holding up two spiders.Oh my God! That really creeps me out.
http://www.blackfive.net/main/2004/04/camel_critters.html
Iraqi Press Monitor
Institute for War and Peace Reporting (IWPR) This is a truly great site. It shows excerpts from Iraqi daily newspapers (translated into English).
The Institute for War and Peace Reporting (IWPR) is an international media development charity. IWPR is led by senior journalists and peace researchers, with staff drawn from established media such as the BBC, The Guardian and Reuters.
http://www.iwpr.net/index.pl?iraq_ipm_index.html
The Institute for War and Peace Reporting (IWPR) is an international media development charity. IWPR is led by senior journalists and peace researchers, with staff drawn from established media such as the BBC, The Guardian and Reuters.
http://www.iwpr.net/index.pl?iraq_ipm_index.html
Before Easter in Baghdad
Iraq&Iraqis (Iraqi blogger fm Baghdad)
2004_04_01_iraq-iraqis_archive.html#10815960290930465
...for sure I wasn’t the only Iraqi who did so, because I so streets full of cars and people, I cant say it was as normal as it was ten days ago, but people are trying to act normal.http://iraq-iraqis.blogspot.com/
Today I attended my building site and met with my Sadir city workers who still come to work and they are being more convinced every day that the coalition is trying to eliminate only trouble makers.
From my meetings with Iraqi people I can feel more people are convinced to stay away from clashes and troubles by staying home and not to get out only for urgent matters and leave the coalition and IPs to do their job.
I came to office today after a car drive in Baghdad (Karada, Dora, Jadriya, Mansor, Bayaa) and all those places were normal but not crowded as they were. But I heard about clashes in Adhamiya.
I don’t like being only a reporter, but it’s important to give a true picture about the situation just to equalize the bad reports on TV stations. I saw some yesterday (and guess what TV station) as usual Arabiya, Who were putting a report about Faluja with pictures full of armed men with black clothes and Mullahs and Sadir pictures, Which means the pictures were from Sadir city not from Faluja, besides more unfinished speeches form Iraqi people. Changing facts is an art for them. I know some would say why you watch these stations?, actually I don’t, I watch Hurra TV, but we must know about the enemy too...
2004_04_01_iraq-iraqis_archive.html#10815960290930465
Who would you vote for?
Iraq Net (Iraqi news in English)
Current poll - Who would you vote for as the new President of Iraq?
The winners are:
In the first rank:
Adnan al-Pachachi [21.5%] - Shia member of the Iraqi Governing Council - head of Independent Democrats Movement - an educated westernized liberal
Mohammed Bahr al-Ulloum [20.6%] - a Shia cleric from Najaf - IGC member - a highly respected religious scholar viewed as a liberal by the public
In the second rank:
Ahmed Chalabi [13.6%] - secular Shia member of the IGC - head of the Iraqi National Congress - favorite of the US government
Ibrahim al-Jaafari [13.2%] - a Shia medical doctor representing the Islamic Dawa Party (i.e. Grand Ayatollah Ali al-Sistani) on the IGC - devoute anti-Baathist - Sistani's brother-in-law
http://www.iraq.net/index.php?
module=advanced_polls&func=display&pollid=12&results=1
Current poll - Who would you vote for as the new President of Iraq?
The winners are:
In the first rank:
In the second rank:
http://www.iraq.net/index.php?
module=advanced_polls&func=display&pollid=12&results=1
Friday in Iraq
Deeds (CPA official in Iraq)
2004_04_01_deeds_archive.html#108159240690612523
Well. Very quiet. The bad guys promised to attack and occupy the Green Zone, take over the major cities and storm the Sheraton hotel.http://deeds.blogspot.com/
I was on the back veranda of the Palace after supper when we heard the mortar fired across the river to our right. Stood there for a bit & then heard it land off to our left. Later we determined that it landed near the Sheraton. So all last night we saw repeated film of one darn mortar hole at the tennis courts next to the Sheraton. Over & over. Then the announcers ask various talking heads – Is it over? Have we failed?
One mortar produces a lot of gloom & doom...
...The foreign press is at the Sheraton so the bad guys were going to storm it. New principle of war: Don’t attack the military – attack the press.
Also the Iraqi police were broadcasting from their cars that anyone seen on the streets with an AK would be shot. No warning...
...Iraqi security. Still doing fairly well. Not perfect & we will keep training more to bring them up to strength. But, again, not the gloom and doom that is preached on US TV.
Coalition has retaken many cities. Some interesting sights as the main population is glad to get rid of the thugs that brought about the latest violence.
But then, that's now a sound bite or film clip.
Anyway, it was a good Friday.
2004_04_01_deeds_archive.html#108159240690612523
Newspapers? Who Reads Them?
Roger Simon
When I got up this morning, my LA Times was at the door with the headline "Thousands in Fallouja Flee; Council Totters". Good thing there's no exclam after "totters," I thought, then we'd really be in trouble... at which point I tossed aside the newspaper without reading it and turned on the computer for the Iraqi blogs. After all, why get my news from people who a. don't speak Arabic, b. don't really know the country and c. have gleaned most of their information from official sources like the military and government spokespeople and are naturally skeptical of them (I would be too, but so what?)?http://www.rogerlsimon.com/archives/00000847.htm
My first stop was the blog Iraq the Model, where I have gone often in recent days. Do I know who they are and what their biases are? Not really, but everyone's biased and at least the people here are knowledgeable. In any case, the person signing his name Ali today is placing the current violence in a context that is part of split in the Shia movement going back to the Seventh Century, between those who rely to some extent on God's will for power (the Sistani people) and those who take a more Maoist-barrel-of-a-gun view of God's will (the Sadir people). Taking the historical view, Ali has the most optimistic vision of the current situation. He concludes (but you should read it all for the background):
So what's good about this riot? As I said this is a very old dream that is strongly rooted to the conscience of the majority of the Shea'at. And with the freedom of speech and with the defeat of the Arab Sunni and with the support and motivation from Iran, this was bound to happen. It could've been worse if a leader with more brains and popularity than this clown carried it.
This riot should be and will be crushed sooner or later, because of the ignorance of the leadership and the lack of support of the majority of Iraqis including Shea'at which made those fanatics resort to terrorizing the people to show that they have the support of the Iraqis like their demand for a general strike which was associated with clear threats.
Another good outcome of this riot is that it showed that the influence of clerics including Sistani, is much smaller than they and their followers were claiming. I've heard it from most of the Shea'at that the whole Iraq supports Sistani and that the Americans don't dare to defy him! They really believed their illusions. Now it appears that the fatwa of Sistani didn't have any significant effect on the Americans' determination to end this riot, nor it convinced the fanatic Shea'at to stay calm. Even the GC paid no attention to him and showed readiness to use force if it is needed.
When this riot will be crushed, and it will be, Sistani and all the clerics will no longer seem as strong as they seemed before, and once they see the 'wholly' name Al-Sadir in handcuffs, they will think a million times before committing a similar stupidity in the future. Even some members of the GC with its religious, tribal and ethnic composition, proved to be short of meeting the challenge. This should clear the political field from these traditional representatives of the Iraqis and surly Iraqis in the future will be forced to search for alternatives once they realize how hypocrite, feeble and lacking their current leaderships are.
This will certainly not happen tomorrow, nor will it happen soon after crushing this riot, but certainly the results will make Iraqis aware of the fact that their leaders are actually not as smart and strong as they look, and that their religious, tribal and ethnic groups will not provide them with their needs. Once that happen they will start to reconsider their goals and their loyalty and the voice of reason, logic will certainly be more heard once the horns of ignorance get silenced or ignored by the majority.
Take a Deep Breath
New York Times
...Pundits and sages were spinning a whole series of mutually exclusive disaster scenarios: Civil war! A nationwide rebellion!...http://www.nytimes.com/2004/04/10/opinion/10BROO.html?hp
...We're at a perilous moment in Iraqi history, but the situation is not collapsing. We're in the middle of a battle. It's a battle against people who vehemently oppose a democratic Iraq. The task is to crush those enemies without making life impossible for those who fundamentally want what we want...
...The ruthless and hyperpoliticized Sadr has spent the past year trying to marginalize established religious figures, like Grand Ayatollah Ali al-Sistani, who come from a more quietist tradition and who believe in the separation of government and clergy. Sadr and his fellow putschists have been spectacularly unsuccessful in winning popular support. The vast majority of Iraqis do not want an Iranian-style dictatorship. Most see Sadr as a young, hotheaded murderer who terrorizes people wherever he goes.
He and his band have taken this opportunity to make a desperate bid for power, before democratic elections reveal the meagerness of their following...
...He is exploiting wounded national pride. He is capitalizing on the Iraqis' frustration with the American occupation (they continually overestimate our competence, then invent conspiracy theories to explain why we haven't transformed Iraq).
Most important, Sadr has the advantages that always accrue to fascist thugs. He is vicious, while his opponents are civilized...
...Sadr's domestic opponents are ill-equipped to deal with him. The police have revealed their weakness. Normal Iraqis are doing what they learned to do under Saddam; they are keeping their heads down. Clerics like Sistani, who operate by consensus, do not want to be seen siding with outsiders against a fellow Muslim...
...Iraqis may be frustrated with the Americans, but they don't want to jump from Baath fascism to theocratic fascism. In a February poll, only 10 percent of Iraqis said it was acceptable to attack Americans. In Kut yesterday, CNN reported, local tribesmen, disgusted by Sadr's violence, rose up against his troops...
...the most influential Shiite groups in Iraq, such as the Dawa and SCIRI parties, are invested in the process of building the new Iraq. Their policies don't jibe with ours, but they have a stake in a democratic future and would love to see Sadr eliminated...
...This week I spoke with leading Democrats and Republicans and found a virtual consensus. We're going to keep the June 30 handover deadline. We're going to raise troop levels if necessary. We're going to wait for the holy period to end and crush Sadr. As Joe Lieberman put it, a military offensive will alienate Iraqis, but "the greater risk is [Sadr] will grow into something malevolent."...
...Over the long run...the task is unavoidable. Sadr is an enemy of civilization. The terrorists are enemies of civilization. They must be defeated.
Fear and Loathing
“I have an uneasy feeling that many on the intellectual left are fearful that America will lose its next war amid massive casualties – but are even more fearful that America may win with minimal casualties."
Robert Fisk, on his readers
A Spanish Lesson
New York Times
By NICHOLAS D. KRISTOF
http://www.nytimes.com/2004/04/10/opinion/10KRIS.html?hp
By NICHOLAS D. KRISTOF
...Mr. Zapatero should announce that all 1,300 troops pulled out of Iraq will be immediately placed in Afghanistan. A major Spanish deployment there would make a huge difference in stabilizing that country, and it would underscore that Spaniards are willing to shed their blood to fight Islamic militants, so long as there is a U.N. mandate and a clear plan...Good Idea.
http://www.nytimes.com/2004/04/10/opinion/10KRIS.html?hp