All opinions posted. None too pathetic or contrived. Everyone gets their say.

"...even the wicked get worse than they deserve." - Willa Cather, One of Ours

Friday, May 21, 2004

A Marine in Iraq

USA Today
by Maj. Ben Connable
RAMADI, Iraq - This is my third deployment with the 1st Marine Division to the Middle East. This is the third time I've heard the quavering cries of the talking heads predicting failure and calling for withdrawal. This is the third time I find myself shaking my head in disbelief.

Setbacks and tragedy are part and parcel of war and must be accepted on the battlefield. We can and will achieve our goals in Iraq...

Waiting for war in the Saudi Arabian desert as a young corporal in 1991...

The panicky predictions failed to come true...Nobody from my platoon died. Strength, ingenuity and willpower won the day. Crushing the fourth-largest army in the world in four days seemed to crush the doubts back home.

[...]

In the spring of last year, I was a Marine captain, back with the division for Operation Iraqi Freedom...

[...]

...Mourning our losses quietly, the Marines drove to Baghdad, then to Tikrit, liberating the Iraqi people while losing fewer men than were lost in Desert Storm.

In May of last year, I was sitting with some fellow officers back in Diwaniyah, Iraq, the offensive successful and the country liberated from Saddam. I received a copy of a March 30 U.S. newspaper on Iraq in an old package that had finally made its way to the front. The stories: horror in Nasariyah, faltering supply lines and demonstrations in Cairo. The mood of the paper was impenetrably gloomy, and predictions of disaster abounded. The offensive was stalled; everyone was running out of supplies; we would be forced to withdraw. The Arab world was about to ignite into a fireball of rage, and the Middle East was on the verge of collapse...

Returning to Iraq this past February...

Just weeks ago, I read that the supply lines were cut, ammunition and food were dwindling, the "Sunni Triangle" was exploding, cleric Muqtada al-Sadr was leading a widespread Shiite revolt, and the country was nearing civil war.

As I write this, the supply lines are open, there's plenty of ammunition and food, the Sunni Triangle is back to status quo, and Sadr is marginalized in Najaf. Once again, dire predictions of failure and disaster have been dismissed by American willpower and military professionalism.

[...]

...as a professional, I have the luxury of putting politics aside and focusing on the task at hand. Protecting people from terrorists and criminals while building schools and lasting friendships is a good mission, no matter what brush it's tarred with.

Nothing any talking head will say can deter me or my fellow Marines from caring about the people of Iraq, or take away from the sacrifices of our comrades. Fear in the face of adversity is human nature, and many people who take the counsel of their fears speak today. We are not deaf to their cries; neither do we take heed. All we ask is that Americans stand by us by supporting not just the troops, but also the mission.

We'll take care of the rest.
Quite refreshing.

From my reading of the military blogs, this opinion is nearly unanimous among our troops in Iraq.

It is always true that the local commander has the best view of the local situation. For example, the troops in Vietnam knew that the situation there was a complete disaster while members of Congress thought everything was going along just swell. On the other hand, the troops now in Iraq seem to be very positive about our chances of success, while some members of Congress seem to be panicking. The idea that we can evaluate the situation better here in the States than our guys can on the ground in Iraq is ludicrous.

As in Vietnam, when the troops on the front lines start telling us that things are a disaster, that is when I will believe it to be true. Untill then I will take the hysterical media reports and talking heads blathering doom-filled scenarios with a big bag of salt.

Gen. Zinni and his like are all fine American military men. But they are not on the ground in Iraq. Therefore their opinions are no more dispositive than my own.

Comments: Post a Comment

<< Home