All opinions posted. None too pathetic or contrived. Everyone gets their say.

"...even the wicked get worse than they deserve." - Willa Cather, One of Ours

Friday, June 04, 2004

Weeping for America's Lost Goodness

Salon (liberal)
In a commencement address to the New School University on May 21, former Kennedy advisor Theodore Sorensen laments "the loss of this country's goodness and therefore its greatness."
This is not a speech. Two weeks ago I set aside the speech I prepared. This is a cry from the heart, a lamentation for the loss of this country's goodness and therefore its greatness.

Future historians studying the decline and fall of America will mark this as the time the tide began to turn -- toward a mean-spirited mediocrity in place of a noble beacon.

For me the final blow was American guards laughing over the naked, helpless bodies of abused prisoners in Iraq...I cannot remain silent when that country is in the deepest trouble of my lifetime.

[...]

Our greatest strength has long been not merely our military might but our moral authority. Our surest protection against assault from abroad has been not all our guards, gates and guns, or even our two oceans, but our essential goodness as a people. Our richest asset has been not our material wealth but our values.

[...]

Our founding fathers believed this country could be a beacon of light to the world, a model of democratic and humanitarian progress. We were...

What has happened to our country? We have been in wars before, without resorting to sexual humiliation as torture, without blocking the Red Cross, without insulting and deceiving our allies and the U.N., without betraying our traditional values, without imitating our adversaries, without blackening our name around the world.

Last year when asked on short notice to speak to a European audience and inquiring what topic I should address, the chairman said: "Tell us about the good America, the America when Kennedy was in the White House." "It is still a good America," I replied. "The American people still believe in peace, human rights and justice; they are still a generous, fair-minded, open-minded people."

...Thirty years ago, America's war in Vietnam became a hopeless military quagmire; today our war in Iraq has become a senseless moral swamp.

...Surely America, the land of the free, could not lose the high moral ground invading Iraq, a country ruled by terror, torture and tyranny -- but we did.

Instead of isolating Saddam Hussein...we have isolated ourselves. We are increasingly alone in a dangerous world in which millions who once respected us now hate us.

[...]

All this is rationalized as part of the war on terror...On the contrary, our conduct invites and incites new attacks and new recruits to attack us.

[...]

True, we have not lost either war we chose or lost too much of our wealth. But we have lost something worse -- our good name for truth and justice...

[...]

We are no longer the world's leaders on matters of international law and peace. After we stopped listening to others, they stopped listening to us. A nation without credibility and moral authority cannot lead, because no one will follow.

...We are deemed by many to be dangerously aggressive, a threat to world peace...

Yet we are also charged...with...indifference -- indifference toward the suffering of millions of our fellow inhabitants of this planet who do not enjoy the freedom, the opportunity, the health and wealth and security that we enjoy; indifference to the countless deaths of children and other civilians in unnecessary wars, countless because we usually do not bother to count them; indifference to the centuries of humiliation endured previously in silence by the Arab and Islamic worlds.

[...]

...If we can but tear the blindfold of self-deception from our eyes and loosen the gag of self-denial from our voices, we can restore our country to greatness...
God that's depressing.

But I am not quite certain which America Sorensen is referring to. It seems very little like the America I live in. I find it very difficult to understand how Sorensen or any American can look at the Abu Ghreeb picutres and say to themselves, "that is my America". Our warriors in Iraq are the best of this great nation. They are a tribute to its decency, honesty and courage. The creatures smiling in those pictures have nothing to do with America or Americans. It is totally alien.

I suspect that even the families of the accused prison guards would see nothing of America in those pictures. If I could hold up the pictures of these atrocities before them and ask, "Is this America?" - I am certain they would reply, "No, that is not the America I live in -- that is not who we are."

Maybe it's part of the Red State/Blue State dichotomy. I am a Blue who lives in Red country. I suppose that if I was a Blue living in Blue country, then Sorensen's lament would make sense in some way. Although I fail to see how it might.

Sorensen appears to be describing some alien land with which I am unfamillar. Why has he lost faith in America? How could anyone be so closed off from the real America that they could lose faith in our ideals?

There is a profound goodness in my America; in the America that I experience every day. Maybe Sorensen should spend a month vacationing in Washington or Oregon. I suspect he would find it educational.

Comments: Post a Comment

<< Home